Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

CC2020 Database Feedback: English County Squads

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Lynx54321
    replied
    Originally posted by Lynx54321 View Post
    Another point on Gloucestershire but not player related. Gloucestershire rebranded from red to yellow about 4 years ago.

    1. Are the t20 strips updated?

    2. Can we get the red in the badge changed to yellow? Can do this for you if you send me the image file.

    Little things like this go a long way.
    Any update on this Sureshot?

    Leave a comment:


  • benj_2904
    replied
    Originally posted by benj_2904 View Post




    couple of points on the above:

    Trego - v.agg is correct for him imo His strike rates are down compared to the new crop of attacking batsman, I think agg is fair.
    Duckett - v.agg is right for him too imo, he's probably one of the most aggressive FC batsmen in england Yep, he's staying V Agg.
    Clarke - does actually open in the majority of OD and T20 games, so again this is correct for him Yep, he's staying OD/20over opener.

    Banton - agree, does deserve to be V.Agg Hmm, I'm questioning myself again. His 20 over SR is V Agg, but the others aren't. Need a think on this!

    Malan - agree, should be Agg As per previous page, will stay average for now.
    Olivier - don't believe he bowls more than mid-high 80's so is RMF imo Been 90+ when I've seen him, but very subjective!

    overall agree that the squads look great & agree with most of the feedback too

    Thanks for your help.

    no problem

    on the Tom Banton point, I think the key factor for me is that he’s most successful to date as a T20 player (recognised by big bash selection etc) so his stats there I think should govern his aggression

    You had your convincing hat on and I've changed Banton to very aggressive.
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-14-2020, 04:36 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lynx54321
    replied
    One other point on Somerset. I think Davies should be a FC opener. He finished the season there and given Somersets paucity of openers (Abell prefers the top/middle order too) it's generally accepted he's a stick on as FC opener now amongst fans.

    Changed.
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-14-2020, 04:35 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lynx54321
    replied
    Another point on Gloucestershire but not player related. Gloucestershire rebranded from red to yellow about 4 years ago.

    1. Are the t20 strips updated?

    2. Can we get the red in the badge changed to yellow? Can do this for you if you send me the image file.

    Little things like this go a long way.

    Leave a comment:


  • Heisenberg
    replied
    Leis - Butchart has been released. Harry Funnell been released. Nathan Bowley missing. Colin Ackermann possibly all rounder? https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/cricket/49226917

    I've released Butchart and Funnell, added Bowley. Changed Ackermann to an all-rounder, removed his opening status as he hasn't done so in a couple of years.
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-14-2020, 04:33 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Heisenberg
    replied
    Derbyshire - Mark Watt has been released. Released
    Durham - Angus Robson has definitely been released. Stuart Poynter has retired from Irish cricket. Both of these have been done.
    Glamorgan - Joe Cooke missing. https://www.glamorgancricket.com/new...d-rookie-deals .Added
    Glos - Jacob Lintott released. Available at start of season
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-14-2020, 04:28 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Sureshot
    replied
    Originally posted by Lynx54321 View Post
    Appreciate your comments Sureshot. With George Scott I guess I'm just basing it on the desire Middlesex had to keep him coupled with Gloucestershire considering it a slight coup to get him. He was rated by Middlesex fans who were disappointed to lose him and I think he'll come into his own with Gloucestershire. The game currently rates him too poorly to get anywhere near a first XI (I've never seen the AI give him a game in all my CC saves) so thought a slight boost considering he'd played games and secured a positive move was due.

    Regarding Byrom I must confess my comment on his England ambition is based on the fact I work with a friend of his!
    The ability system will have taken last season in to account and looks like he's not too badly related, certainly looks a bump from the CC19 database.

    Regarding Byrom, yes, there's going to be a few shake ups in county cricket in the future, Kolpak was set to end at the end of this season, but that might not be the case now with the pandemic.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lynx54321
    replied
    Appreciate your comments Sureshot. With George Scott I guess I'm just basing it on the desire Middlesex had to keep him coupled with Gloucestershire considering it a slight coup to get him. He was rated by Middlesex fans who were disappointed to lose him and I think he'll come into his own with Gloucestershire. The game currently rates him too poorly to get anywhere near a first XI (I've never seen the AI give him a game in all my CC saves) so thought a slight boost considering he'd played games and secured a positive move was due.

    Regarding Byrom I must confess my comment on his England ambition is based on the fact I work with a friend of his!

    Leave a comment:


  • Sureshot
    replied
    Originally posted by MateGaming View Post
    Suggested edits for Hampshire:

    Edit: Forgot to mention in my original feedback - Donald was expected to be out for the majority of the season with a knee injury.
    I've set Donald up to have a knee injury until the end of August. Articles say he's expected to miss the season, but tough to really know, my thought was it might be nice for him to be available for last couple of FC matches.


    Leave a comment:


  • cizza
    replied
    Originally posted by MateGaming View Post
    [/LIST]Northants:
    • Cotton no longer at the club Made available
    • Wouldn't have said Buck was as quick as RMF Agreed
    • I'd always thought Levi was a OD opener as well as T20, but I could well be wrong Changed, opened in all of his LIst A appearances last season.
    • G White is white-ball only Yes, retired from FC.
    Having watched all Northants' home games last year, agree with most of the above, Cotton was signed for the 2019 season but failed pre-season fitness tests so didn't join the squad as planned. Levi is defo an opener for OD and White is on a white ball only contract.

    I'd say Buck should remain as a RMF, He's certainly a touch faster than Sanderson and Hutton and looking back over a couple of Sky games, admittidly a small sample size, he's bowling between 83-85mph. Also despite his low career strike rate I'd say his batting is now Agg, scored three half centuries last year, with 287 runs @ 31 with a strike rate of 76.94. I've moved Buck back to to RMF, he used to be RMF and was always more consistently mid-80s when I watched him. Aggression rating is interesting, he did well in FC last year, but that does look a bit of a one off for now. Fascinating strike-rate in FC last year for him compared to all his other career SRs.

    Would bump Graeme White up to Ave or Agg, has played a few handy cameos in t20. Tough on such a small sample size, as he's now retired from FC, i've moved him up to average.

    Vasconcelos should also be Agg, his FC strike rate probably doesn't reflect it, but he does bat in an aggressive style. I feel the numbers still support average. 53 SR in FC last season, did better in OD last season but career SR is only 80. Will stay as average for now.

    Ashraf should be RMF, definitely faster than RFM, could arguably be RF but probably not quite. Changed

    Adam Rossington hasn't opened in OD for at least the last couple of years, so would have him as an opener in T20 only. Changed, thanks.

    There's a strong argument to say Rob Keogh should be classed as an all-rounder these days, a tricky one as has developed from a part-timer to being used more and more, especially in Championship cricket, he is used as Northants main spinner, and only Sanderson and Hutton bowled more FC overs than him last year. Hmm, another tricky one, I think I will use the same thoughts as behind changing Labuschagne to just a batsman. He bowled a lot in FC last year, not a great average and in Div 2, which isn't a strong standard.
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-12-2020, 04:45 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lynx54321
    replied
    George Scott (Gloucestershire) and Scott Steele (Durham) were also selected in Scotland's training squad pre COVID so should be Scotland eligible in game. Changed both to Scottish nationality.

    Squad at bottom of this page: http://www.cricketscotland.com/early...he-new-season/
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-12-2020, 04:06 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lynx54321
    replied
    Gloucestershire Feedback

    Cockbain is a limited overs specialist and I think should be at least Avg if not Agg. Super tricky, have moved to average.

    Willows has often opened for the 2nd XI. Changed

    Scott should be Avg or at least Def and needs an ability boost based on CC19 where he is awful. Changed to average. As for his ability, his real life record is pretty poor so far?

    Charlesworth is more Def or Avg than U.Def. also in addition to a strong performance on the last day of the season he was a key performer for England under 19s over the summer. He's a big batting prospect so I feel should be upgraded ability wise too.

    His Strike-Rates are:
    FC: 38
    LA: 63
    U19Test: 42
    U19ODI: 65

    He'll be staying U Def for now.


    Howell very rarely opens now, more of a middle order finisher. Good point, reverted to all-rounder middle order.

    J.Taylor (all rounder) has styled himself as very much a rapid scoring t20 finisher, I'd say he should be V.Agg based on recent t20 performance and general strike rates. His FC SRs are low, but I think his combined SRs, it's fair enough to say he should be V.Agg, so I've changed him to that.

    In addition to the Price brothers, Dominic Goodman also signed a pro contract. He's a seam bowling all rounder who is an aggressive batsman too. Added

    Somerset feedback:

    Abell should be avg aggression, massive improvement to his limited overs batting last season. Has been changed to average.

    Lammonby needs improved on his CC19 ability after featuring a lot for Somerset's t20 side last season. Player abilities are dynamic and will take last season in to account.

    Goldworthy is an all rounder. Changed

    Aldridge is pretty quick, I'd say RMF. Changed

    Eddie Byrom has England ambitions and isn't going to play for Zimbabwe any time soon. I think his nationality should be English similar to how Nick Welch, Ryan Higgins and Adam Rouse are already portrayed. I don't think he's English qualified yet, all I can find online is that he holds an Irish passport, but that's irrelevant for this season in English Domestic as Irish nationality counts as overseas unless retired from international cricket.
    Last edited by Sureshot; 06-12-2020, 04:36 PM.

    Leave a comment:


  • Lojoda
    replied
    Originally posted by MateGaming View Post
    Warks:
    • Don't think Banks opens He's opened a bit, but seemed to settle at #6 last season, so have changed to middle order.
    • Hain should be Avg to represent his huge success in OD format. Also pretty sure he's not an opener in any format. Opened quite a bit in the past, especially in OD (averages 60 at #2), but not recently. I'm going to leave defensive, I feel that fairly reflects his SR in all formats.
    • Garrett RFM Changed
    • Milnes no longer at the club, same with Wainman. Wainman also LFM. Milnes removed as he's now a former proffesional cricketer according to online sources. Made Wainman available and changed to LFM.
    Worcs:
    • Don't know when D'Oliveira last opened He opened for 9 innings in 2018, but averaged 9 so hasn't opened since...
    • Libby arguably V. Def. Also don't think I've seen him open. He opened in 7 of 10 innings last year in FC. He's right between V Def and Def, FC SR was lower last season than season before (poor form probably accounting for that). His OD SRs keep him on Def for me.
    • Whiteley maybe V. Agg? Possibly the same with Wessels though Agg seems fair. Agreed.
    • Finch RFM. Haven't seen much of him, but career s/r would suggest he is far from Agg. Changed to v def and RFM
    • Not sure I'd consider Leach a fully-fledged all-rounder He's batted up the order quite a bit, averages ~25 in FC and OD at #8. Will leave as is.

    Yorkshire:
    • Malan maybe Agg? Has had great success in limited overs in recent years. Tricky, in 2018 his SRs were low, good last year in 20 over, but I think he should be kept as avg for now.
    • Should Pooran be higher than Agg? Think that's fair. I've also retired him from FC as he's played FC in 5 years.
    • Thompson faster than RM Now RFM
    • Olivier probably close to being RF Changed to RF.
    • Maharaj seems close to being V. Agg Don't agree, left as is.
    • Tattersall not an opener in any format. Changed.



    All in all, looking good though, great work. Looking forward to the new release and hope this feedback helps

    Your feedback has been fantastic, thank you.
    Whilst Pooran hasn't played FC for over 5 years, that's mainly because of Injury and international games. Recently Michael Holding said he should be in the test team

    Leave a comment:


  • cricketfan7
    replied
    Originally posted by Sureshot View Post

    Thanks for your feedback, I've replied in bold in your post.

    Someone else mentioned Charlesworth should be RM, looking at videos I agreed. Little bit tricky, I've always felt Bopara is the top limit of RM, he will sometimes bowl a ball at 80mph, but averages lower than that. How quick is he compared to say Benny Howell (RFM), David Payne (LFM) or Ryan Higgins (RM)?

    Tough to know at times, Jofra bowled some very quick 90+ spells for England last summer, but then also had some in the 80s. It's quite subjective.
    I would say that if Bopara is RM then Charlesworth should also be RM for now. He certainly might become quicker over the summer, but for now that's what I would say. He is certainly much more a batsman anyway, as shown by his performances in the U19 WC - opened the batting and didn't bowl much (if at all) so I hope that is replicated in game.

    Price (T) is quicker than Charlesworth as far as I know, not sure how much quicker though.

    Leave a comment:


  • Barneyb64
    replied
    Never seen him play, but Gus Atkinson is listed as a Bowler on the Surrey website, and he looks pacy when I've seen him in nets at lunchtime! https://www.kiaoval.com/squad-players/gus-atkinson/

    Leave a comment:

Working...
X